Skip to content
Cast Iron FAQ

How-To Guides

Everything you need to start cooking well and make smart cookware decisions — written for real beginners and improving cooks.

Cast Iron Skillet Identification: Foundry Marks, Gate Marks and Era Registry
Anyone holding a skillet upside down over the sink, squinting at a mark they cannot read — or at no mark at all — and trying to work out what they actually own.11 min read

Cast Iron Skillet Identification: Foundry Marks, Gate Marks and Era Registry

Flip the pan over and look for a raised bar running edge to edge across the base. That is a gate mark, and it dates the casting to roughly pre-1890 on its own, before you read a single letter. If there is no gate mark, the identification order that works is heat ring, then handle profile, then cooking-surface finish, then mark style — and a completely unmarked pan is still placeable to a decade by mass and rim wall thickness alone.

Read guide
Is My Cast Iron Ruined? Damage Triage for Cracks, Warp, Pitting and Flaking
Someone looking at a pan they are half-convinced is scrap, wanting a real answer before they either bin it or spend a weekend on it.10 min read

Is My Cast Iron Ruined? Damage Triage for Cracks, Warp, Pitting and Flaking

Two conditions genuinely retire a cast iron pan: a crack that goes all the way through, and rust that has eaten through the section. Everything else — pitting, flaking, warp, grey scale, black residue, a rocking base — is either cosmetic or restorable. You tell them apart with a straightedge, a set of feeler gauges and a ring test, not by eye.

Read guide
Best Oil to Season Cast Iron: Cured-Film Hardness Across 15 Fats
Anyone standing in front of a shelf of bottles trying to work out which one actually builds a film that lasts, rather than which one somebody swore by on a forum.10 min read

Best Oil to Season Cast Iron: Cured-Film Hardness Across 15 Fats

Use grapeseed or plain canola. Both sit in the semi-drying band with iodine values around 110-145, which builds a film hard enough to resist a metal spatula and flexible enough not to shed in sheets. Flaxseed produces the hardest and glossiest film of anything on the shelf and is also the most notorious flaker, because a highly cross-linked coating carries internal stress it eventually resolves by letting go of the iron.

Read guide
How to Season Cast Iron: Oven Temperature and Coat Schedule by Pan Class
Someone about to put a pan in the oven who wants a temperature, a dwell time and a coat count that match the pan they actually own.10 min read

How to Season Cast Iron: Oven Temperature and Coat Schedule by Pan Class

Wipe on a semi-drying oil, wipe it back until the pan looks dry, and bake at 450-465°F for 60 minutes with the pan upside down on the middle shelf. Cool it in the closed oven. Repeat until the surface closes — three or four coats on a machine-ground face, five or six on a coarse sand-cast one. The target temperature is the oil's smoke point plus 25-50°F, which is why the oil you choose sets the oven dial.

Read guide
Cast Iron Sticky After Seasoning: Eight Causes Diagnosed by Feel
Someone with a pan that came out of the oven tacky, gummy or streaky and wants to know which of the eight faults it is before they strip anything.9 min read

Cast Iron Sticky After Seasoning: Eight Causes Diagnosed by Feel

Tacky all over means the oven never reached polymerisation temperature. Gummy patches mean too much oil. Sticky only when hot means an under-cured film; sticky only when cold usually is not seasoning at all, it is cooking-fat residue. Only one of the eight faults on this page needs a full strip, and it is the one caused by using a non-drying oil.

Read guide
Rust Removal on Cast Iron: Method Table by Rust Depth
Someone with an orange pan — anything from a faint bloom after a wet night to a barn find under flaking scale — who needs to pick a method that removes the rust and not the pan.10 min read

Rust Removal on Cast Iron: Method Table by Rust Depth

Grade the rust by depth before you pick a method. Surface bloom comes off with coarse salt and oil in ten minutes; heavy scale and pitting want electrolysis, which removes oxide and no sound metal at all. Vinegar works and is the method that eats pans, because once the oxide is gone the acid starts on the iron underneath — 30 minutes maximum on a thin vintage casting, checked every ten.

Read guide
Can You Use Soap on Cast Iron? Nine Cleaning Methods Measured Against Seasoning Loss
Anyone who has just squirted washing-up liquid into a skillet and felt a flicker of guilt about it.9 min read

Can You Use Soap on Cast Iron? Nine Cleaning Methods Measured Against Seasoning Loss

Yes. Modern dish detergent is a surfactant with a pH around 7 to 9 and it cannot dissolve a polymerised seasoning film — the never-soap rule dates from lye soap with free alkali still in the bar. What genuinely strips a cured film is strong alkali above about pH 12, pyrolysis above roughly 700°F, and abrasion, which is why the oven self-clean cycle and a dishwasher cycle both take a pan back to grey iron while a bottle of Dawn does not.

Read guide
Cast Iron Skillet Size Chart: Number, Rim Diameter, Cooking Surface and Weight
Someone holding a pan with a number on the bottom, or choosing between a 10.25 and a 12, and wanting to know what they'd actually be cooking on.9 min read

Cast Iron Skillet Size Chart: Number, Rim Diameter, Cooking Surface and Weight

The number cast into a vintage pan is a wood-range stove-eye size, not an inch measurement, and the inch figure on a modern pan is the outside rim diameter. Both overstate the flat floor you cook on by roughly 1.7 to 2.4 inches, and a machined vintage No. 8 gives you more usable surface at a pound less weight than a modern 10.25-inch pan of the same nominal class.

Read guide
Cast Iron Dutch Oven Size Chart: Quarts, Interior Dimensions and What Actually Fits
Anyone deciding between a 4.5 and a 5.5 quart, or wondering whether the pot they own will take a whole chicken and a boule.9 min read

Cast Iron Dutch Oven Size Chart: Quarts, Interior Dimensions and What Actually Fits

Quart capacity measures water to the brim and tells you nothing about whether a 4 lb chicken clears the lid. Interior diameter and wall height are the specs that decide, and the practical answer for most households is 5.5 quarts at roughly 10.2 inches interior diameter and 4.6 inches deep — the smallest size that takes a 2 lb boule with oven-spring headroom and a 4 lb bird without wedging it.

Read guide
Bare Cast Iron vs Enamelled vs Carbon Steel: 18 Measured Differences
Someone with one of the three already and trying to work out whether the other two would earn their hook space.10 min read

Bare Cast Iron vs Enamelled vs Carbon Steel: 18 Measured Differences

Carbon steel is roughly 25 to 40% lighter at the same diameter and reaches 400°F in about half the time, but drops 110 to 160°F when a cold steak lands on it against 60 to 90°F for bare cast iron. Enamelled cast iron carries the same iron mass with a glass skin that conducts at 1 to 2 W/m·K against the iron's 46 to 55, which costs it surface responsiveness and buys it complete acid tolerance.

Read guide
Cast Iron Brands Compared: Wall Thickness, Weight and Surface Finish by Maker
Anyone deciding whether a $200 skillet does anything a $30 one doesn't, with a real spec sheet in front of them.10 min read

Cast Iron Brands Compared: Wall Thickness, Weight and Surface Finish by Maker

Three specs separate every current maker: surface finish (sand-cast, machined or polished), rim wall thickness (2.4 to 4.6 mm), and mass at a given diameter (4.0 to 8.1 lb for a 10-inch pan). Those three predict release, thermal response and how the pan feels in one hand better than any brand story, and the makers charging the most are mostly selling you the first spec.

Read guide
Cast Iron on Glass, Induction, Electric and Gas: Heat Source Compatibility Table
Anyone about to set a heavy skillet on a glass-ceramic cooktop and wondering whether they're about to hear a crack.9 min read

Cast Iron on Glass, Induction, Electric and Gas: Heat Source Compatibility Table

Yes, with three conditions: lift the pan rather than sliding it, keep the setting at or below medium-high, and check the base is flat within about 0.5 mm across its diameter. On glass-ceramic the failure mode is a damaged cooktop rather than a damaged pan, and gate-marked or heat-ringed vintage pans are the ones that scratch, because only a raised ring or scar touches the glass.

Read guide